I'm not exactly sure why Academy voters
thought this film was worthy of nomination, maybe it was a slow year,
but I feel this film falls short of top 5 film worthiness for me.
Don't get me wrong, I did enjoy the film and recommend it, but
there's just a bit too much far-fetched and contrived plot
motivations to keep this from really taking root in reality and
moving me sufficiently. Damon's character is so repugnant I find it
difficult to buy that a smart, attractive Harvard undergraduate who
is independently wealthy and has a bright future ahead of her would
ever see anything within him to fall so madly in love with him
considering his demeanor, prodigy or not. What makes this film
ultimately work is the credible acting, with a deserved Oscar going
to Williams as the psychiatrist, and there's some genuinely
insightful commentary that proves the Oscar for screenplay was
deserved as well. Despite my quibbling, this film's moments of
insight pulls it above the imaginary storyline to make it worthwhile
and inspiring viewing nonetheless.
Back to Qwipster's Movie
Reviews
<